Providence’s Democrat mayor is doubling down on his war against a mural honoring Iryna Zarutska, the Ukrainian refugee brutally murdered last year by a career criminal with a rap sheet full of prior arrests.
Even after the original artwork at The Dark Lady nightclub was scrubbed under pressure, a new version is already underway at another spot in the city. Yet Mayor Brett Smiley and local media keep branding the project “divisive” – a transparent attempt to memory-hole the deadly consequences of soft-on-crime policies that endanger everyone, including legal immigrants chasing the American dream.
In video statements, Smiley made his position crystal clear, claiming “A movement was funded by some right-wing billionaires. It wasn’t bringing us together as a community.”
Providence Mayor on why wants the Iryna Zarutska mural to come down:
— Western Lensman (@WesternLensman) April 2, 2026
“A movement was funded by some right-wing billionaires."
“It wasn't bringing us together as a community."
In other words: The mural is a powerful reminder of the disastrous failures of his party’s policies. pic.twitter.com/5gyVdNjfiF
“This has not brought us closer together as a community, in fact, has been quite divisive and even a little bit ugly,” Smiley continued.
He added that while the city wouldn’t prevent another business from hosting it, “again I’m not sure that it’s helpful to the community.”
Providence Mayor defends his call for removal of Iryna mural:
— Western Lensman (@WesternLensman) April 2, 2026
“This has not brought us closer together as a community, in fact, has been quite divisive and even a little bit ugly."
Says if someone else wanted to house the mural:
“We wouldn’t prevent them from putting it… https://t.co/dhr4IWnfd3 pic.twitter.com/FVXZFDkXYw
As we highlighted last week, Smiley demanded the removal of the mural, declaring that it “does not reflect our values.”
Now the artist behind the project, Ian Gaudreau, is pressing ahead at a new site on Atwells Avenue at Opa The Phoenician on Federal Hill.
A local reporter covering the development described the effort as “a divisive mural coming here to Atwells Avenue honoring Iryna Zarutska.”
The owner of the restaurant – an immigrant family-run business – sees it differently, viewing the tribute as a way to honor a fellow immigrant’s tragic story without the political spin.
A new Iryna Zarutska mural is being planned at another location in Providence.
— Western Lensman (@WesternLensman) April 4, 2026
The reporter describes the project as “divisive." https://t.co/dEyW9IVyT6 pic.twitter.com/cVvyTHDaNN
Iryna, 23, was stabbed to death on a Charlotte, North Carolina, light-rail train in August 2025 by Decarlos Dejuan Brown Jr., who had been arrested 14 times before.
Her death became a rallying point for those demanding accountability from a justice system that repeatedly releases dangerous repeat offenders back onto the streets. The national “Remember Iryna” mural campaign, which includes this project, highlights exactly that failure.
The first mural went up on the side of The Dark Lady, a well-known LGBTQ club in downtown Providence. It was part of a broader effort spotlighting victims of violent crime amid debates over bail reform and sanctuary-style leniency.
Smiley’s office quickly weighed in, with the mayor framing the artwork as politically motivated rather than a simple memorial.
Critics fired back that the real ugliness is a system that lets predators roam free while officials scramble to erase reminders of the human cost. As one reply to the reporting put it, “This is how we win. For every Iryna mural taken down, three must go up.”
Elon Musk responded directly to one of the mayor’s defenses: “What a hateful mayor.”
What a hateful mayor
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) April 3, 2026
Of course, George Floyd murals and BLM tributes faced no such scrutiny despite sparking far more actual division and unrest.
The resistance shows Americans are tired of officials who prioritize narrative control over truth and public safety. A legal Ukrainian immigrant is murdered by a repeat offender, and instead of focusing on fixing the broken system, the response is to scrub the memorial because it makes the wrong people uncomfortable.
This saga is bigger than one mural in Providence. It’s a microcosm of the left’s refusal to confront the real-world results of their policies: skyrocketing crime, eroded trust in institutions, and a willingness to punish victims and their memory rather than the criminals.
As the new Iryna Zarutska tribute takes shape on Federal Hill, it stands as a quiet act of defiance – proof that not everyone is willing to let inconvenient truths disappear.
Providence residents and freedom-loving Americans everywhere should keep pushing back. Memorials to innocent victims aren’t “divisive.” Ignoring the policies that enable their deaths is.
Your support is crucial in helping us defeat mass censorship. Please consider donating via Locals or check out our unique merch. Follow us on X @ModernityNews.
More news on our radar
Where was this A-Clown’s objections to murals and statues glorifying the black criminal, robber, drug dealer and woman assaulter George Floyd? Crickets !
This is the same mayor who last year had no objection to the so-called “Palestinian flag” being hung at Providence City Hall. Actually, having her portrait on the side of the Dark Lady, a night club for trannies and other perverts, was not much of tribute to Iryna. The new location is much nicer for her tribute.
And if the perp was white and the victim black, would the mayor object?
Stay classy, Yankees.
The Mayor is wrong and is showing how racist he is. There is nothing wrong to celebrate a beautiful life of a legal migrant working to better her life. How in the world can you find division in that.